Skip to content
NewSee how this site publishes in seconds
Halftone

Design

Rethinking empty states, part 3

What we kept, what we cut, and why. The small decisions that make the product feel quieter. How we chose, tested and shipped the details.

Ivo Santos
Published 2 min read

Motion should explain, not decorate. If an animation does not tell you where something came from or where it went, we remove it. This post covers what we changed, why, and what it means for you.

#The constraint

Good defaults are invisible. You notice them only when they are missing, usually at the worst possible moment.

We tested each change with the people who use the product all day. The best feedback was rarely about how something looked, and almost always about how it felt to repeat.

We started from the text. Body copy sets the rhythm for everything else, so we fixed its size and line height first and derived the rest of the scale from there.

  • Report problems in plain language
  • Run independent steps in parallel
  • Cache what never changes
  • Keep the previous version one click away

#What we would do differently

Consistency is a feature you ship once and maintain forever. Our lint rules now catch one-off sizes and colors before they reach review.

Every color in the product now maps to a role, not a hue. Designers pick "border" or "muted text", and the system decides what that means in light and dark mode.

Hairlines carry more structure than you would expect. A single one-pixel rule can replace a card, a shadow and a background, and the page gets quieter.

#Where we started

Motion should explain, not decorate. If an animation does not tell you where something came from or where it went, we remove it.

Good defaults are invisible. You notice them only when they are missing, usually at the worst possible moment.

We tested each change with the people who use the product all day. The best feedback was rarely about how something looked, and almost always about how it felt to repeat.

“A cache key must include everything that can change the output, and nothing that cannot.”
Dee Marsh

#What changed

We started from the text. Body copy sets the rhythm for everything else, so we fixed its size and line height first and derived the rest of the scale from there.

Consistency is a feature you ship once and maintain forever. Our lint rules now catch one-off sizes and colors before they reach review.

Every color in the product now maps to a role, not a hue. Designers pick "border" or "muted text", and the system decides what that means in light and dark mode.

Diagram of the request path before and after the change
Figure: the request path, before and after.

#The details

Hairlines carry more structure than you would expect. A single one-pixel rule can replace a card, a shadow and a background, and the page gets quieter.

Motion should explain, not decorate. If an animation does not tell you where something came from or where it went, we remove it.

Good defaults are invisible. You notice them only when they are missing, usually at the worst possible moment.

#Rolling it out

We tested each change with the people who use the product all day. The best feedback was rarely about how something looked, and almost always about how it felt to repeat.

We started from the text. Body copy sets the rhythm for everything else, so we fixed its size and line height first and derived the rest of the scale from there.

Diagram of the request path before and after the change
Figure: the request path, before and after.
How we designour typescaleHALFTONE / JOURNAL

Design4 min

How we design our type scale

How we chose, tested and shipped the details. Good defaults, explained. What we kept, what we cut, and why. The small decisions that make the product feel quieter.

Jun Calder / Gus Heller
The detailsbehinddensitysettingsHALFTONE / JOURNAL

Design4 min

The details behind density settings

The small decisions that make the product feel quieter. What we kept, what we cut, and why. Good defaults, explained.

Gus Heller
In praise ofour typescaleHALFTONE / JOURNAL

Design10 min

In praise of our type scale

How we chose, tested and shipped the details. The small decisions that make the product feel quieter. Good defaults, explained.

Dee Marsh / Jun Calder